Los Arroyos Mexican Restaurant & Bar
Sun–Thu 11:00am–9:00pm; Fri–Sat 11:00am–10:00pm
- 137 E New York St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
- 317-405-8171
- Last verified: September 2026
137 E New York St, Indianapolis, IN 46204 — Open in Google Maps
Menu
Entradas
- Ceviche Tostada$19
Fresh white fish marinated in lime juice, cilantro, onions and tomatoes, served on a crispy corn tortilla with guacamole
0 - Chile con Queso$15
Strips of roasted pasilla chiles mixed with melted cheeses served with homemade corn tortillas
0 - Diego's Nachos$14
Corn tortilla chips with melted cheese, black beans, salsa fresca, sour cream and guacamole
0 - Gringa$18
Flour tortilla filled with melted cheese and grilled pork in adobo sauce with pineapple and onions, topped with sour cream and guacamole, served with Mexican rice
0 - Homemade Guacamole$8(Small)$14(Large)
Mashed avocado with tomatoes, lime juice and onions, served with a basket of freshly cut and fried chips
0 - Homemade Queso$5(Small)$8(Large)0
- Homemade Soup$80
- Quesadilla$13
Flour tortilla filled with melted cheese topped with sour cream and guacamole, served with a side of molcajete salsa
0 - Taquitos Dorados$13
Crispy chicken or beef taquitos (6 bite sized) served with salsa fresca, queso fresco, sour cream and guacamole
0 - Top Shelf Chunky Guacamole$16
Chunky guacamole made fresh from avocado, tomatoes, lime juice, onions and cilantro, served with a basket of freshly cut and fried chips (serves 2-4)
0
Ensaladas — add chicken 5 / steak 6 / shrimp 7 / salmon 9 / white fish 9
- Caesar$14
Romaine lettuce mixed with homemade Caesar dressing, tomatoes, parmesan cheese and croutons
0 - California$14
Chopped romaine lettuce, roasted corn, whole black beans, carrots, cherry tomatoes, jicama, red onions, mango and avocado, served with homemade cilantro Caesar dressing
0 - Mama's$14
Romaine lettuce, mixed greens, roasted veggies, roasted corn, cherry tomatoes and avocado, served with homemade ranch or balsamic vinaigrette dressing
0 - Mexican Caesar$14
Chopped romaine lettuce, roasted corn, whole black beans, julienne red bell pepper and cheese, topped with sliced avocado and blue corn tortilla strips, served with homemade cilantro Caesar dressing
0 - Quinoa$14
Mixed greens, quinoa, julienne beets, pomegranate seeds, jicama, almonds, mint and radish served with passion fruit dressing
0 - Tostada Ranchera$14
Crispy flour tortilla shell with Mexican rice and black beans, cheese, shredded lettuce, sour cream and avocado, served with homemade cilantro Caesar dressing
0 - Tropical$14
Mixed greens with avocado, jicama, red onions, mango and cherry tomatoes, served with homemade passion fruit dressing
0
Tacos — two tacos on homemade corn tortillas served with Mexican rice and beans or Caesar salad
- Al Pastor$19
Grilled pork in adobo sauce with pineapple and onions. Two tacos on homemade corn tortillas served with Mexican rice and beans or Caesar salad
0 - Carnitas$19
Braised pork slow cooked, Michoacan style. Two tacos on homemade corn tortillas served with Mexican rice and beans or Caesar salad
0 - Crispy Tacos$19
Shredded chicken or shredded beef served with lettuce, cheese, and salsa fresca. Two tacos served with Mexican rice and beans or Caesar salad
0 - Grilled Chicken$19
Two tacos on homemade corn tortillas topped with onions and cilantro, served with Mexican rice and beans or Caesar salad
0 - Grilled Steak$19
Two tacos on homemade corn tortillas topped with onions and cilantro, served with Mexican rice and beans or Caesar salad
0 - Rajas con Queso$17
Sauteed pasilla peppers and onions with melted cheese. Two tacos on homemade corn tortillas served with Mexican rice and beans or Caesar salad
0 - Rib Eye Tacos Especial$29
Three grilled rib eye tacos on homemade corn tortillas with cebolla asada, frijoles charros, cilantro and melted cheese
0 - Vegetables$17
Roasted veggies seasoned with garlic topped with melted cheese. Two tacos on homemade corn tortillas served with Mexican rice and beans or Caesar salad
0
De La Parilla
- Carne Campestre$26
6 oz New York steak on top of grilled Anaheim chile stuffed with Mexican cheese, served with Mexican rice, beans, baby grilled onions, guacamole and homemade corn or flour tortillas
0 - Fajitas$19(Veggie)$22(Chicken)$23(Steak)$26(Shrimp)$27(Salmon)
Grilled bell peppers, tomatoes, and onions on a hot sizzling platter, served with sour cream, guacamole, Mexican rice, beans and homemade corn or flour tortillas
0 - Tony's Alambres$15(Veggie)$16(Chicken)$18(Steak)$21(Shrimp)
Three homemade corn tortillas with grilled bell peppers, onions and tomatoes, topped with melted cheese
0
Del Mar
- Arroyo Enchiladas$22
Grilled fish and shrimp, roasted veggies and melted cheese enchiladas topped with salsa verde served with Mexican rice and beans or tropical salad
0 - Crab Enchiladas$23
Dungeness crab, creamy chipotle sauce, cilantro and melted cheese enchiladas topped with creamy salsa verde and mango salsa served with Mexican rice and beans or tropical salad
0 - Tacos del Mar$22
Two soft tacos with grilled white fish or shrimp, shredded cabbage, creamy chipotle salsa and chopped mango salsa on homemade corn tortillas served with Mexican rice and beans or Caesar salad
0 - Tacos Gobernador$22
Three lightly toasted homemade corn tortillas filled with melted oaxaca cheese, sauteed shrimp, pasilla pepper and onions, garnished with purple cabbage and served with guacamole and gobernador salsa
0
De La Casa
- Arroyo Molcajete$28
A dish big enough for two! Grilled chicken or steak, served with grilled chorizo, nopales (cactus), jalapeño, Mexican onions and queso enchilado in a molcajete with roasted salsa, served with homemade corn or flour tortillas
0 - Arroz con Pollo$18
Grilled chicken placed around homemade Mexican rice, served with our queso sauce
0 - Chile Relleno$17
One roasted pasilla pepper stuffed with queso fresco and fried with egg white batter, covered with salsa roja and served with Mexican rice and beans
0 - Enchiladas Rojas$19
Two enchiladas with grilled chicken or steak and melted cheese, topped with red sauce and queso fresco, served with Mexican rice and beans
0 - Luisa's Pozole$21
Traditional Mexican soup made from hominy with chicken or pork, garnished with cabbage, radish, avocado, lime, cilantro and onions, served with homemade corn or flour tortillas
0 - Maria's Enchiladas$19
Two enchiladas with grilled chicken or steak and melted cheese, topped with green sauce and melted cheese, garnished with salsa fresca, queso fresco and micro greens, served with Mexican rice and beans
0 - Sopes Regionales$17
Two thick handmade corn tortillas topped with melted cheese, brown beans, shredded beef or shredded chicken, lettuce, salsa roja, chopped tomatoes and queso fresco, served with Mexican rice
0 - Tampiqueña$24
Grilled skirt steak served with a cheese enchilada, brown beans, avocado and homemade corn tortillas
0
Tu Combinacion — create your own combination plate served with Mexican rice and beans or Caesar salad
- Crispy Taco$15(1 Item)$19(2 Items)$22(3 Items)
Shredded Chicken / Shredded Beef
0 - Enchilada Roja$15(1 Item)$19(2 Items)$22(3 Items)
Cheese / Shredded Chicken / Shredded Beef
0 - Enchilada Verde$15(1 Item)$19(2 Items)$22(3 Items)
Cheese / Pollo Asado / Carne Asada
0 - Soft Taco$15(1 Item)$19(2 Items)$22(3 Items)
Chicken / Steak / Pastor / Carnitas
0 - Sope$15(1 Item)$19(2 Items)$22(3 Items)
Chicken / Beef / Veggies
0
Burritos
- Arroyo$22
Grilled fish and shrimp, roasted veggies, black beans and melted cheese served with Mexican rice, guacamole and sour cream
0 - Chile Relleno$20
Wet burrito with chile relleno and black beans inside, salsa verde and melted cheese outside, served with Mexican rice, guacamole and sour cream
0 - Chile Rojo$18
Shredded beef or shredded chicken in salsa roja, black beans and melted cheese served with Mexican rice, guacamole and sour cream
0 - Chile Verde$18
Marinated stew pork in salsa verde, black beans and melted cheese served with Mexican rice, guacamole and sour cream
0 - Chimichanga$19
Fried burrito with shredded beef, shredded chicken or carnitas, black beans and melted cheese inside served with Mexican rice, guacamole and sour cream
0 - Fajita$18(Chicken)$19(Steak)
Grilled chicken or steak with sauteed bell peppers, tomatoes, onions, cheese and black beans, served with Mexican rice, guacamole and sour cream
0 - Garden$17
Roasted tomatoes, bell peppers and onions with black beans, melted cheese and lettuce served with Mexican rice, guacamole and sour cream
0 - Juanito's$23
Filet mignon, whole brown beans, cheese, salsa fresca and avocado served with mixed greens and passion fruit dressing
0 - Mojado$18(Chicken)$19(Steak)
Wet burrito with melted cheese and black beans inside with salsa roja and melted cheese outside, served with Mexican rice, guacamole and sour cream
0 - Run Away$15(Chicken)$17(Pastor, Carnitas or Steak)
Handheld burrito with brown beans, melted cheese and guacamole
0
Sides
- 1/2 Salad (House, Caesar or Tropical)$100
- Beans$60
- Chicken$80
- Fresh Fish$110
- Mexican Rice$60
- Mexican Rice and Beans$80
- Shrimp$100
- Steak$90
- Tortillas$30
- Veggies$70
Bebidas
- Coffee$40
- Fountain Soft Drinks$40
- Homemade Mexican Aguas Frescas$4
Jamaica, Horchata
0 - Hot Tea$40
- Jarritos$40
- Juices$40
- Mexican Coca Cola$40
- Organic Tropical Iced Tea$40
- Sparkling Water$40
Para los Niños — (for children under 12)
- Kids Meal$13
Choose one: flour quesadilla, two chicken taquitos, cheese nachos, soft taco chicken or steak, chicken tenders, bean and cheese burrito, served with Mexican rice and a small fountain drink
0
Ceviches
- Ahi Tuna Ceviche$22
Fresh ahi tuna marinated in ponzu sauce and sesame oil, mixed with watermelon, jalapeño peppers and black sesame seeds
0 - Ceviche Punta Mita$23
Shrimp marinated in lime juice and passion fruit sauce, mixed with mango, avocado, radish, red pepper flakes, red onions, jicama and cilantro
0 - Ceviche Tatemado$22
Shrimp and octopus marinated in lime juice and salsa tatemada, mixed with red onions, cilantro, cucumber, radish, jalapeño and avocado
0 - Ceviche Tostada$20
Fresh white fish or shrimp marinated in lime juice, cilantro, onions and tomatoes, served on a crispy corn tortilla with guacamole
0
Gourmet Blue Corn Tacos - Especial
- Ensenada Baja$9
Smashed avocado spread on a handmade blue corn tortilla topped with fried lightly beer-battered halibut, topped with purple cabbage, mango salsa and sour cream aioli, served with salsa quemada and fresh lime
0 - Flor de Calabaza$9
Melted cheese on a handmade blue corn tortilla topped with sauteed tomatoes, onions, corn and squash blossom, drizzled with sour cream, garnished with pomegranate seeds and micro greens, served with salsa de molcajete
0 - Monterrey Norteño$9
Smashed avocado spread on a handmade blue corn tortilla topped with grilled filet mignón chunks, Mexican grilled onions and whole brown beans, garnished with queso fresco, served with salsa de molcajete
0
Especiales
- Asado a la Norteña$32
Grilled rib eye steak, frijoles charros, Anaheim chile stuffed with queso fresco, served with corn or flour tortillas, chimichurri sauce and avocado
0 - Chicken Anaheim$22
Grilled chicken with roasted Anaheim chilies, onions, cilantro & tomato in a cream sauce served with rice & homemade corn tortillas
0 - Herbie's Ribs$25
Baby back pork ribs in our spicy homemade barbecue sauce, served with guacamole, handmade corn tortillas and choice of green rice or Caesar salad
0 - Langostino Quesadilla$23
Two large flour tortillas filled with langostino lobster, three types of cheese, caramelized onion & avocado topped with chipotle sour cream sauce, served with guacamole
0 - Rib Eye Fajitas$32
Grilled bell peppers, tomatoes, onions and grilled rib eye steak on a hot sizzling platter, served with sour cream, guacamole, Mexican rice, beans and homemade corn or flour tortillas
0 - Swordfish Kabob$28
Grilled swordfish skewers with roasted onion & bell pepper, topped with our signature tamarindo sauce served on julienne petite crispy potatoes and green rice
0
Weekend Brunch — 10am - 1pm
- Abuelita (Grandma's) Breakfast$16
Chilaquiles (red or green) topped with lightly grilled onions and melted cheese, served with eggs*, brown beans, queso fresco and sour cream
0 - Burrito Americano$15
Scrambled eggs with bacon, brown beans, jack cheese and sour cream with fruit on the side
0 - Carne Azteca$23
Angus New York steak with sauteed onions topped with melted cheese and salsa verde, served with fried eggs*, brown beans and homemade potatoes
0 - Chile Verde and Egg Burrito$16
Scrambled eggs with chunks of chile verde, brown beans and jack cheese with fruit on the side
0 - Chorizo Burrito$16
Scrambled eggs, cheese, Mexican chorizo, brown beans and potatoes with fruit on the side
0 - Enchiladas con Huevos$15
Two cheese enchiladas in salsa roja topped with fried eggs*, served with sour cream, queso fresco and homemade potatoes
0 - Huevos a la Mexicana$14
Scrambled eggs with tomato, onion, jalapeños, cilantro and queso fresco, served with brown beans, guacamole, and flour or homemade corn tortillas
0 - Huevos Rancheros$16
Crispy corn tortilla with a spread of brown beans topped with cheese, fried eggs*, salsa ranchera, queso fresco, avocado and served with homemade potatoes
0 - Johnny's Burrito$14
Scrambled eggs, cheese, brown beans, potatoes, sour cream and guacamole with fruit on the side
0 - La Cura Cruda (The Hangover Cure)$18
Skirt steak sauteed with jalapeños, bell peppers, onions and tomatoes, served with brown beans, sliced avocado, fried serrano pepper, eggs*, and corn or flour tortillas
0 - Machaca Scramble$15
Scrambled eggs with shredded beef, tomato, onion, green bell peppers and cheese topped with cilantro and avocado, served with brown beans and homemade corn tortillas
0 - Short Stack Pancakes$12
Three pancakes topped with butter, maple syrup and fresh berries
0 - Small Side$5
Bacon, fruit, pancake, home potatoes or two eggs
0 - The Village Omelet$16
Grilled chicken or steak with bell pepper, onions and cheese topped with avocado and served with homemade potatoes
0
Drinks
- Aguas Frescas$4
Tamarindo, Horchata, Jamaica
0 - Fresh Orange Juice$50
- Jarritos$40
- Mexican Coke$40
- Mexican Hot Chocolate$50
- Organic Tropical Iced Tea$40
Coffee
- Americano$50
- Café Latte$60
- Classic Cappuccino$60
- Espresso$50
- Mocha$60
Cocktails
- Bloody Mary$120
- Michelada$90
- Mimosa$120
Lunch Specials — lunch-sized meals served Monday-Friday 11:00am until 3:00pm served with fresh chips and homemade salsa
- Arroz con Pollo$15
Grilled chicken placed around with Mexican rice, served with queso sauce
0 - Burrito Mojado$15(Chicken or Steak)
Burrito with grilled chicken or steak and black beans topped with melted cheese and salsa roja, served with Mexican rice, guacamole and sour cream
0 - Chimichanga$15
Fried burrito prepared with shredded beef or chicken, black beans and cheese, served with Mexican rice, guacamole and sour cream
0 - Fajitas$15(Chicken or Steak)
Sizzling meat served with red and green peppers, onions and tomatoes, sour cream, guacamole, Mexican rice and beans with a side of flour or handmade corn tortillas
0 - Gringa$15
Marinated pork with pineapple and onions and melted cheese wrapped in a tortilla and served with guacamole
0 - La Tampiqueña$15
Grilled steak with sautéed onions and one cheese enchilada topped with sour cream, served with refried beans and handmade corn tortillas
0 - Mexican Caesar Salad$15(Chicken or Steak)
Chopped romaine, corn, whole black beans, julienne red pepper and jack cheese topped with sliced avocado & blue corn tortilla strips, served with our cilantro Caesar dressing (half-size salad only)
0 - Milanesa de Pollo$15
Breaded chicken breast served with Mexican rice and your choice of flour or handmade corn tortillas
0 - Mole Enchiladas$15
Enchiladas with grilled chicken and jack cheese topped with mole sauce and ajonjoli seeds, served with Mexican rice and beans
0 - Quesadilla$15(Chicken or Steak)
Flour tortilla with three types of melted cheese, sour cream and guacamole, served with house salad
0 - Soup and Taco Combination$15
Our soup of the day served with your choice of one crispy taco (shredded chicken or beef) or soft taco (pork, grilled chicken or steak)
0
Gourmet Blue Corn Tacos
- Ensenada Baja$15(choose two)
Smashed avocado spread on a handmade blue corn tortilla topped with fried lightly beer-battered white fish, topped with purple cabbage, mango salsa and sour cream aioli, served with salsa quemada and fresh lime
0 - Flor de Calabaza$15(choose two)
Melted cheese on a handmade blue corn tortilla topped with sauteed tomatoes, onions, corn and squash blossom, drizzled with sour cream, garnished with pomegranate seeds and micro greens, served with salsa de molcajete
0 - Monterrey Norteño$15(choose two)
Smashed avocado spread on a handmade blue corn tortilla topped with grilled filet mignón chunks, Mexican grilled onions and whole brown beans, garnished with queso fresco, served with salsa de molcajete
0
Small Sides
- Guacamole$8.00 (small) / $14.00 (large)
Mashed avocado with tomatoes, lime juice and onions, served with a basket of freshly cut and fried chips
0 - Queso$20
- Shrimp$30
- Sour Cream$10
Menu items and prices are approximate and may have changed — call the restaurant to confirm.
Turn off ads for Los Arroyos Mexican Restaurant & Bar
For $9.99/year, we'll remove every ad from your restaurant's page on menuzr — just your menu, photos, and info. No account needed, and no surprise auto-renewals: we'll email you before it expires.
- Pay below with PayPal
- Email us your restaurant's name and city
- We turn off ads on your page — usually within a day
After paying, email [email protected] with your restaurant's name so we can activate it.